News & Insights
6 Questions To Ask Before Hiring A Paid Social Agency
Finding the right paid social agency and knowing what questions to ask before you commit to working with them can be tricky, especially when new digital marketing agencies seem to pop up every other month.
A good agency should be able to explain how they’ll measure success, who will manage your account and what they’ll do to keep performance on track over time.
The best paid social agencies go beyond simply running ads. They take accountability for delivering meaningful business results. Asking the right questions will help you identify an agency that genuinely understands your goals and spot any red flags before signing a contract.
Not only can switching agencies be expensive, but the barrier to entry is relatively low. This has created a crowded market where the quality of agencies can vary significantly, making it important to know exactly who you’re working with before committing to a six-month contract.
At the same time, platform automation has changed what makes a paid social agency valuable. It’s no longer just about managing campaigns or pushing buttons. The real value lies in creative strategy, accurate tracking and a clear approach to driving results for your business.
An experienced agency should give you an answer specific to your audience and business model, not a one-size-fits-all reply. If they recommend every platform without asking about your goals, that’s a red flag.
It’s beneficial to know if an agency has worked with similar business, because it tells you whether the team has the experience to handle your account. They don’t have to have worked with a direct competitor, but they should understand your business and the challenges you face.
Judge agencies on how they measure business outcomes, not on platform metrics in isolation. Clicks, CTR, reach and even in-platform ROAS can look impressive while your actual revenue stays the same. A good agency will connect its reporting to the numbers your business runs on, such as leads that turn into sales, cost per acquisition, revenue and profit.
Creative is one of the biggest drivers of paid social performance, so you need to know who makes it. Ask how they spot creative fatigue; a strong agency will have a regular refresh schedule and will use performance data to decide what to make next.
Keeping ownership and control of your ad accounts, pixel and data should be a non-negotiable.
Expect an audit, onboarding, a testing plan and honest expectations about the learning phase. An agency should also be upfront with the fact that results take time to settle and will show you a clear plan for how performance will improve.
A good agency will ask you just as many questions as it answers. If they aren’t asking about your sales process, margins or leads, they have no way of understanding what success looks like for your business or how to optimise it. Be wary of agencies promising guaranteed results, such as a specific CPL or ROAS, before they’ve even seen your accounts or taken the time to understand your goals.
Another red flag is an agency that constantly focuses on big, ever-growing numbers without putting them into context. Impressive figures might look good on paper, but they can sometimes mask underlying problems or distract from the metrics that really matter, such as ROAS and conversion rates. If an agency is more interested in chasing bigger numbers than demonstrating meaningful results, it’s worth questioning what they’re actually delivering.
Finally, as mentioned earlier, ownership of your ad accounts, pixel and data should be non-negotiable. Be cautious of any agency that insists on running your campaigns through an account they own rather than giving you ownership and control of your own assets.
If you’re looking for a paid social agency to optimise your campaigns and make sure your accounts are in the right hands, we can help. At Circus, our paid social experts build strategies that grow and adapt alongside your business. We pride ourselves on being honest and transparent, keeping you informed about what’s happening in your accounts and how your campaigns are performing.
Get in touch below to schedule your introductory call.
A paid social expert focused on driving results for clients!